More reader feedback. Today’s topic in review:
children’s public behavior. (Names have been changed to protect the guilty.)
Debate Point#1Who knew we had such a wide range of opinions on disciplinary techniques for kids?
Reader Feedback
I understand there are ‘moments,’ but I truly agree with you that some kids are just out of control and their parents need to take charge. Personally, I feel like I good ol’ southern ‘whuppin’ would take care of that mess, but I’m sure I’d be crucified for that statement. […] I understand the occasional moment [of misbehavior] but the problem lies in frequency of such behavior. But what can you say? Any comment I make is met with the “wait till you have kids, […]” line. Oh well, maybe we’ll see.
(Lee Ann asks: Is corporal punishment a Southern thing?)
Debate Point#2
Some people agreed with my original point that parents should be considerate of other people when they take their children out in public.
Reader FeedbackAMEN to "when kids attack"!! I am saying that because I don't have kids yet. Apparently, according to parents, I will change completely when that time comes. I've already told my parents to warn me if I turn into one of "those" parents, so now you are another person to keep me in line! :)
Debate Point#3
Yet some parents point out, we have to look beyond the surface to understand and offer comment on children’s behavior.
Reader FeedbackI am a mom of two boys (one with only two volumes, WAY LOUD and off). I remember my pre-children days when I would look at kids in a store throwing a HUGE tantrum and wonder what was wrong with their parents! The link you made to an MSNBC article had one paragraph that hit the nail on the head! It stated: "Don't get me wrong. As a parent, I have an arsenal that includes the deadly stare, loss of privileges and 'We're going back to the car, RIGHT NOW!"' said Angela Toda, a 38-year-old mother of two small children in College Park, Md. "But the bottom line is, there are certain moments that all kids and parents have — and sometimes your kid is going to lose it in a public place."
Sometimes when you see a parent with a spazzing child, the moment in time you see is not indicative of the way that parent disciplines that child on a daily basis. […] People need to stop jumping to conclusions without all the facts, and give parents the benefit of the doubt in some cases. I'm all for removing/disciplining a child when they throw fits for selfish reasons. But Matt. 7:1 says, "Judge not, lest ye be judged..." Perhaps offering a word of encouragement to the parent would be a first step in helping rectify the situation. Those are my thoughts.... Just wanted to show you another perspective.
Debate Point#4How responsible are parents for their children’s behavior?
Reader Feedback It's been my observation as a real parent (since somehow being single prevents you from seeing the facts clearly), that well-mannered children are - barring the obvious exceptions - a direct result of a parent's efforts, thirst for skill knowledge (books, etc) & prayer. […]
It usually comes down to a lack of courage on the parent's part. They must be willing to do what's best for the kid in the LONG run, not the short. That means constant supervision and often punishment until the kid(s) realize the behavior will reap consistent negativity. A direct correlation to this is - barring the obvious exceptions - most couples can make it on one income if they're willing to make some (generally not great) sacrifices. Again, there's often a serious lack of courage on the couples' part. This is from someone who's doing both (only) by the grace of God & some courage.
My ThoughtsTruly, I do recognize it takes a lot of courage to raise children, and I respect parents. There is probably no one perfect formula for ensuring perfect children, but
again, I’m saying this as a non-parent. I
will tell you that as a potential fish owner, I do find all this discussion fascinating and will take it into account when the time comes for me to take on the challenge, joy, and wonder of being responsible for another living being, i.e. my future fish.