Mel's MeltdownIf you haven't heard,
Mel Gibson was arrested for driving under the influence and made anti-Semitic remarks during the confrontation. It's a sad indication of Gibson's state, and it's an unfortunate blow to the movie that raised so much Christianity awareness.
The Movie... AgainAm I the only one on the planet who never saw
The Passion of the Christ? I've been asked about it. I don't have an impressive explanation. On an embarrassingly simple level, I can only say that I always like the book version better than the movie version. In my mind, I have my own picture of Calvary, and I don't want Gibson's vision imposed on it. Selfish? Close-minded? I'm not sure. It's just the choice I have made for that reason--along with the fact that I'm not sure yet how I feel about an R-rated version of a passion play.
Still... I will echo my initial comments about the film. I'm always glad when people turn to Christ, even if the spurring force is not something I personally endorse. Whatever your view of the film, it did its part to raise a tremendous amount of awareness about Cavalry.
Or Did It?I found a 2004 study that claims the impact of the movie was not that extreme. Here's an excerpt from
"Resurrection Questions about The Passion of the Christ":
Gallup asked "did seeing the movie strengthen your religious faith?" (78% yes). Related, Gallup also asked "did seeing the movie give you a new understanding of what your religious faith is about?" (64% yes).
However, when probing more specifically about changes in religious beliefs or practices, the Barna data reflect a far less profound influence for The Passion. When asked if the film had affected their religious beliefs in anyway, 16% said it had. When asked specifically what these shifts might have been, roughly 3% of the aggregate audience for the film indicated each of the following: 1) a shift in the perceived importance of how they treat others; 2) becoming more concerned about the effects of their life choices and personal behavior; and 3) gaining a deeper understanding of, or appreciation for, what Christ had done for them through his death and resurrection.
As the Barna report notes, despite heavy speculation that the film would serve as a conversion tool for Evangelicals, less than one-tenth of one percent of respondents who had seen the film said that they made a profession of faith or accepted Jesus Christ as their savior in reaction to the film's content.
In ConclusionI'd like to see the research behind the poll because I thought the film made more impact than that. And even though I don't have a personal testimony concerning it, I would think the film carved out its own special place in the canon of mainstream Christian film, if there is such a thing.
Back to GibsonGibson's remarks may cast a negative shadow over the film, but I bet this week's DVD sales and rentals jump up just because of the extra press.