Thursday, November 15, 2007

The Relationship Between 90&9 and.......... Bob Dylan


Many posts the last few months have thrown around ideas as to what makes good music, how to musically get out of a stale box, how to play effectively, how to lyrically make something spiritually legitimate, etc. I would have never imagined finding a music project that, for me, congealed many of the above elements in the most unlikely of characters…Bob Dylan.

I really didn’t know much about Bob, except for hearing his rough, nasally voice braying somewhere where I was basically forced to hear him, as opposed to purposely listening to his music. There is a lot to be said about Bob…I didn’t know he was from Duluth, MN (went there for youth conferences back in the day), didn’t know he went to Greenwich Village in New York and joined up with the counterculture movement and became very popular with his folk singing…didn’t know he came to detest the title of “a voice of a generation” so much that he purposely started producing junk and exhibiting eccentric behavior just to create some space between him and his fan base. Then, in 1979 he had a born again experience and produced three gospel albums, the first of which was entitled “Slow Train Coming.” It is considered one of the greatest gospel albums ever made. It went to number 2 on the charts in the UK and number 3 in the US (as well as platinum). It also won Bob a Grammy Award for best rock vocal performance on “Gotta Serve Somebody.” AND people thought he dove off a diving board into the deep end of a pool with no water.

I downloaded it and have been soaking it in for the following reasons:

1. Sonically, it sounds phenom. You can hear every instrument “breathe.” There is a very solid foundation underneath some amazing guitar, B3, keyboard, and horn splat riffs.

2. The lyrics are obviously Biblically based; however, they are not just gratuitious. I agree that the name of Jesus, and other Christian themes should never be lost, but on the flip side, marketing music to a certain demographic and throwing the name Jesus around (at best), or watering down the approach to appeal to a wider audience (at worst), seems to be CCM’s modus operandi. It seems to me that every genre, be it AP music, secular, CCM, all of them – can get stuck in a rut until someone restless comes along and moves the trail. Then it happens all over again. I’ve probably digressed, but what Dylan puts together in “Slow Train” is a set of lyrics that leave you thinking, and even though you might not agree with his worldview, he still manages to plant a seed by the colorful and at times driving word arrangements.

3. Take the music, add the lyrics, and then put Bob’s wheezing, gasping, cracking, nasally, “fading in and out” voice, and all of the other things you’re not supposed to do vocally, and suddenly you have lyrics sung in raw emotion buttressed by outstanding musicianship. Who would have thunk it?

Some of my friends think I’m nuts and won’t listen at all because of Bob’s counterculture stigma, my kids want to listen to “Man gave names to all the animals” over and over, and my wife has been listening, …but only for the entertainment value. Me? I’ve got a greater appreciation for what makes music resonate long after it was first distributed.

8 Comments:

Blogger aahrens said...

You know, you make a good point about getting "stuck in a rut until someone restless comes along and moves the trail." It seems we love to swing the old pendulum. I'll admit Dylan's voice grates on every nerve I've got. But when people don't listen because of that, it makes me think," AHA!! You DO listen to the words and not just the music, don't you now!" :)

I get your point here. In my post, I wasn't trying to swing the pendulum to the other extreme. I think I was thinking more along the lines of the fact that we love our new music so much (and rightfully so) and are so quick to defend it and decry the old, all the while not paying attention to the fact that we need to express exactly what we believe because of the educational quality of music. We sing about everything else, why not the Jesus?

Now you've got me wanting to go out and get this CD..!

AA

November 16, 2007 10:07 AM  
Anonymous Steads said...

Great resource on Dylan and his gospel period here at:

http://dylangospel.blogspot.com/

November 16, 2007 7:42 PM  
Blogger The Pave said...

Ann,
Points well taken on the lyrics discussion.

Steads,
Thanks for the pointer...went there and found it fascinating, especially Wexler's discussion of how he made the studio sessions work. That was very informing, as well as all the other tidbits.

November 16, 2007 9:47 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The PAVE-

Perhaps you should reconsider her thoughts on using Jesus' name songs. I am taken aback by your liberal thinking while being the administrator for an ultra- conservative congregation. Does the Senior Pastor share your same feelings regarding music? I am appalled to think that your Pastor would disfellowship the group "Cadence" and "Bro. Larry Carter" while his own administrator and group PAVE have such hard rock on their project. Please give this some serious consideration.

November 24, 2007 2:51 AM  
Blogger The Pave said...

Oh, boy. You post anonymously, then go after items that do not pertain to the post. Your items about "disfellowshipping" "Cadence" "Larry Carter" and "hard rock" is erroneous and misinformed. I would be more than happy to elucidate for you personally @kmbrad3@sbcglobal.net, if you wish, but I refuse to drag this ezine into mud slinging...especially since you have in no wise directly addressed the post...will await your email with your real name.

November 25, 2007 7:14 PM  
Blogger deanna said...

Just for the record, I had read your blog abd enjoyed it when it was first posted. I did not read the comments, I just was informed about the previous comment made to you by a friend who saw it. I want to go on record as saying that no one who has anything to do with "Cadence" had anything to do with that comment, the girls do not even frequent this website, and I certainly had nothing to do with it. I am extremely upset that their name was dragged into this, and you are correct, the comment had nothing to with your topic.

Deanna

November 26, 2007 1:13 PM  
Blogger The Pave said...

Deanna,
I'm hearing you and thanks. I certainly have no ill-will against any of the names mentioned: the girls from Cadence are very talented, as is Larry Carter and I still consider him a friend.

November 26, 2007 2:13 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

August 6, 2008 3:36 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home