In Defense of Apostolic Writers
Our sister blog Notes recently debated the absence/presence of quality Apostolic music. Amid the growing debate, our Letters’ Editor took a moment to point out that there are Apostolic songwriters and producers among our ranks.It’s funny because after 5 weeks on the road in 4 different districts this summer, I’ve noticed that (perhaps out of self-defense to others or maybe a fear of becoming too self-centered among ourselves) we tend to be quick to criticize our movement. Over the last few weeks I’ve heard everything from the “there’s no good Apostolic music” line to myths about Bible colleges to the misconception that Apostolics are an uneducated, ignorant lot and on and on. I don’t know if it’s because we’re echoing the rhetoric we’re scared the “more aware” in the world propagate, or if it’s just a matter of ignorance on our parts as to what our brothers and sisters across our fellowship are truly accomplishing.
However, after meeting hundreds of people the last few months, I can honestly say that I’m outrageously optimistic about the intelligence, talent, and anointing of our church family. There are so many exciting, creative things happening. Unfortunately, I find that those among us who’d like to criticize our lack of (fill in the blank with complaint du jour) only do so to feel somehow superior themselves. To circulate these near-sighted myths only shows me an ignorance on the critic’s part and a lack of getting “out there” and seeing what other Apostolics are creating. Those who lament how backwards the organization is on their myspace, but haven’t visited a church outside their area code in six months, may need to rethink their criticisms.
Why all that? Because like Kent mentioned, sometimes with the dialogue of this blog, it sounds as though no one is writing. That’s simply not true. How thrilled I was, as you can imagine, when I saw Kevin’s short story posted. We are writing. And we are getting published, even if not everyone in our fellowship knows it. And Kent is interviewing Pulitzer winners. And we have Apostolic librarians teaching at major universities. So, yes, we are being recognized in the greater literary world. And we are step by step carving a niche that fosters creativity and action in place of criticism.
My point, despite the 3 paragraph rabbit trail at the beginning of this post, is that there are good things happening in our movement, including writing advances. For some reason many among us turn to criticism, but I’m asking that we choose not to make ungrounded complaints. We are not blind to our imperfections, but there are also exciting accomplishments. Instead of throwing around inaccurate blanket statements such as “no Apostolics are writing music/literature,” we should acknowledge the artists among us and support them.
Won’t you join us in our efforts? Tell a young (or old) aspiring writer about this blog. Find a writing partner with whom you may share your work. Promote reading and writing among those with whom you have influence. We are making progress, and if we work together with positive attitudes, I have no doubt that our writing efforts, like the many other creative arts being developed by Apostolics, will blossom beyond our wildest expectations.


15 Comments:
Lee Ann,
How good is a timely word! I'm afraid I tend to be one of those critics you're talking about, which is surprising, even to me, because so many of apostolic people I know personally are wonderfully talented and whole-heartedly engaged in their callings. God is equipping the called with gifts that will benefit His kingdom in this world and bring Him the greater glory. My perspective is changing with prayer from one of frustration to one of faith. May God help us to see His hand at work!
You folks keep up the good work, now, you hear? You're a wonderful inspiration to me as I continue working to hone the gifts God has given me in the writing field. This fall, I'll be starting my junior year as an English major, and I've never been more excited, let me tell you.
Deep blessings,
Rebecca Newton
Rebecca, thanks for sharing! Your efforts are exactly what I hope we never fail to appreciate. Keep up the great work.
We are blessed to have many talented people in our church family, and I encourage us to recognize this and create an atmosphere of support one for another--just like in this blog.
Lee Ann,
You are so right! There are so many people doing great things - but we often forget to talk about that.
Keep up the supportive blogging - one of those great fields of work that don't get the mention...
I never doubted apostolics were writing — just scan the PPH catalogue. There are also those who publish in venues outside of the apostolic movement who are off the mainstream “radar screen” so to speak.
I agree with Lee Ann about refraining from ungrounded and unfounded criticisms, but I do have a question: What would you, or anyone else who would like to reply, consider to be the right kind of criticism that we need as aspiring writers in order to improve our work?
“Those who lament how backwards the organization is on their myspace, but haven’t visited a church outside their area code in six months, may need to rethink their criticisms.”
We only have five churches and one area code in our whole state and we still find it difficult to get around to other churches. How easy it is to become isolated in our own little bubble.
Steve, I appreciate your feedback. That's a good line of questioning about what type of criticism is useful. I didn't mean to include peer review critiques in my definition of criticism. I think looking at one another's work and offering honest assessments with evidence from the text is very helpful. My main point was that we need to avoid unjustified generalizations.
I am glad you mentioned the unique situation you have in your district. On a side note, this just goes to prove how much more we need to recognize that the world is bigger than our own backyards. For example, I grew up in Louisiana and was blessed to be surrounded by many fellow believers. In my high school we had about 30 Apostolics. This week in Wisconsin, of the 65 campers, 20 said they were the only Apostolics in their high schools. Talk about an eye-opener; I was in shock. I only bring that up to say that it's easy to become near-sighted and assume everyone is like you/your church. The truth is that we have a diverse church body, and we have to be careful not to generalize. In this spirit of not blindly complaining about lack of (fill in the blank), I think we need to recognize that a lot is going on around the globe. My hope is that we can become more cognizant of that and support one another, not the least of which is in our writing efforts.
The entire constituency in our two-state, 10-church, district is probably under 400 people. Our church is 41 years old, this year, and I believe Vermont was one of the last states to get an apostolic church. We were the first in 1967. Churches in New England tend to grow slow. We averaged 79 in Sunday morning service in 2007. We’ve been higher and we’ve been lower, but we have never had more than 149 for any given service, and that was only once. We are one of the largest churches in our district with most of the other churches averaging under 50 people and less than 30 being more like it. It is quite different from the Bible belt.
I knew you were not lumping all criticism into the negative category, but I wanted to ask the question because I have run into the more “enlightened” people who would. It seems as though a multitude of “sins” are now acceptable as long as people feel good about themselves. Heaven forbid we should risk their fragile self-esteem by offering some good, constructive, criticism. I have even been finding this more and more in the apostolic church. I think all serious writers wither have good self-esteem, or they have a good coping mechanisms, since it can’t be all that fun to receive a number of rejection letters while trying to publish something.
Does some of this indicate the Ap movement has grown too big for the "old boys network," w/out the news distributing network keeping pace? Is there any central place that shares this good news you talk about? Are we so large (& somewhat successful, w/out having many/any celebrities) that this mid-level success is now taken for granted?
"Is there any central place that shares this good news you talk about?"
Hmm... 90 & 9 perhaps?
"grown too big for the 'old boys network'"
You may have a point. I have been in AP churches all my life from 20-2,000 members and I never hear of events out side of the church (ie youth rallies, revivals, etc) until weeks later, if ever. I only learned of 90&9 a year ago. Most likely some of the blame gos to myself but even in the Bible belt we are not ding a good job of getting the word out on anything.
Could it be that we are isolated to our local church/section/district because we are faithful to that church?
I don't have time to go visit other churches and see the successes that they have accomplished (with the direction of God) because I am too busy helping grow my local church.
We definitely need a news network for just that reason! Anyone want to start that group on Everyone's Apostolic? Which, by the way, needs that apostrophe but doesn't have one? :)
Do it somewhere other than Everyone's Apostolic. I don't want to join a group to get my news. This old curmudgeon doesn’t really care for social networking sites anyway. I once opened an account on Facebook to see what our young people were doing. Turns out, unless I was their “friend” I couldn’t find out much of anything. My Facebook account withers on the proverbial cyberspace vine.
“Could it be that we are isolated to our local church/section/district because we are faithful to that church?”
Faithfulness to a local church is one thing (and a good thing at that), but there is no excuse in this information age to be isolated.
"Do it somewhere other than Everyone's Apostolic. I don't want to join a group to get my news."
I think your right, although social networking sites can be used for this a blog format would most likely be a better fit. We now (just went up this year) have The Apostolic Report and EA that dose some of this job but three sites (90&9, EA and Apostolic Report) and a hand full of personal blogs seems to be rather a small cyberfootprint.
But face to face interaction can not be replaced. We have multichurch events for the under 18 frequently but nothing for 20+ other than chaperoning for the youth events and the occasional conference. Such events may not have been needed 40 years ago but are needed now. I have been to churches that preach agents fellowshiping events but without them we are isolated.
John is right about the limited events for 20somethings, but the Forum is coming up on September 26-27 in St Louis! www.iqforum.net
Don't miss it!
Whewwwwwww neighbor!
"Those who lament how backwards the organization is on their myspace, but haven’t visited a church outside their area code in six months, may need to rethink their criticisms." Them's some fightin' words! :) I agree with you. As one who tends to see the sunny side of things, I'm COMPLETELY optimistic about the AP movement and what we are offering. Sometimes I think we have shut ourselves out from fellowship because we not longer attend rallies/conferences/etc.. like we once did. REmember when it was the THING to go to youth rallies, etc..? I remember those days and I'm not old! Are we getting to cool for ourselves? Yes, we're sluggish about getting ourselves in the game and out in plain sight sometimes, but I see such great strides that I'm not going to criticize.
AA
Post a Comment
<< Home